Japan cupid profiles is dating cousin in japan normal

Is dating your cousin normal in japan

Protestant churches generally allow cousin marriage, [] in keeping with criticism of the Catholic system of dispensations by Martin Luther and John Calvin during the Reformation. Bittles, Alan; Black, Michael September Further information: Cousin marriage law in the United States. The Middle East has uniquely high rates of cousin marriage among the world's regions. Cousin marriage has been allowed throughout the Middle East for all recorded history. Genetic education programs directed at high-school students have been successful in Middle Eastern countries such as Bahrain. The ceremony closes with symbolic offerings of little tree twigs, recognized sakaki, that happen to be given to Goodness. Are dating your cousin normal is somewhat ambiguous. In a cousin marriage is wrong. Retrieved 27 March Instead, countries that uses badoo dating site tinder what is new match raison d'etre of cross-cousin marriage could be found within the institution. By the s, the number of bans had doubled. It was estimated in that 0. Namespaces Article Talk. Retrieved 10 September Suberu, Rotimi T. Help Community portal Recent changes Upload file. In Ohio 's Geauga CountyAmish make up only about 10 percent of the population but represent half the special needs cases. Of those, in 64, the spouses were of the same lineage. Baba of Karo; Smith, Mary Felice Neem contact met ons op. The daughters of Eleazer also married the sons of Eleazer's brother Kish in the still later time of David 1 Chronicles Hajnal, J. Heeft u specifieke wensen? Cousin marriage was more frequent in Ancient Greeceand marriages red lights for dating a japanese girl do they have dating apps in japan uncle and niece were also permitted. Adult Child Teen. Anthropologist Jack Goody said that cousin marriage was a typical pattern in Rome, based on the marriage of four children of Emperor Constantine to their first cousins and on writings by Plutarch and Livy indicating the proscription of cousin marriage in the early Republic.

Navigation menu

Augustine by the fifth century. Research among Arabs and worldwide has indicated that consanguinity could have an effect on some reproductive health parameters such as postnatal mortality and rates of congenital malformations. My life. Bittles, Alan H. While readily conceding that banning cousin marriage cannot be justified on genetic grounds, Saletan asks rhetorically whether it would be acceptable to legalize uncle-niece marriage or "hard-core incest" between siblings and then let genetic screening take care of the resulting problems. Prem, Chowdhry Finally, in the Telegraph reported that cousin marriage among the British Pakistani community resulted in children being born every year with genetic disabilities. One source from the s states that cousin marriage was less common in Cairo than in other areas. A History of Matrimonial Institutions. Incest: why does it seem accepted in japan.

She reportedly got the idea after learning that cousin marriage is an acceptable form of marriage among some cultural groups that have a strong presence in Minnesota, 100 free fetish dating sites simple hookup login the Hmong and Somali. Consanguinity seems to affect many polygenic traits such as height, body mass index, intelligence and cardiovascular profile. Cousins are not included in the lists of prohibited relationships set out in the Hebrew Biblespecifically in Leviticus and and in Deuteronomy. Case studies. Banned with exceptions 1. Part of a series on the. January—March Consanguinity rates were generally stable throughout the 4 many years that information can be found, although second-cousin marriage seems to have been reducing in favor of first-cousin marriage. Cross-cousin marriage in effect help for single women relocating raleigh north carolina funny online dating profile names the anthropologist to control for biological degree by studying a situation where the degree free online dating england most popular inexpensive adult dating site prohibited and prescribed spouses were equal. Women and the law in the Roman Empire. Matrilateral cross-cousin marriage is actually found simply by some anthropological researchers for being correlated with patripotestal jural right, that means legal rights or responsibilities of the dad. Retrieved 15 January They relate this to an old Arab proverb: "Myself against my brother; my brother and I against my cousin; my cousin, my brother and I against the outsider. Cousin marriage was historically practised by indigenous cultures in AustraliaNorth AmericaSouth Americaand Polynesia.

The Published Key To Japanese Brides Found

However, these results may principally reflect village endogamy rather than consanguinity per se. Just a certain ambiguity in a couple days, it seem accepted in japan? Anthropologist Jack Goody said that cousin marriage was a typical pattern in Rome, based on the marriage of four children of Emperor Constantine to their first cousins and on writings by Plutarch and Livy indicating the proscription of cousin marriage in the early Republic. Spencer speculate that legal bans persist in part due to "the ease with which a handful of highly motivated activists—or even one individual—can be effective in the decentralized American system, especially when feelings do not run high on the other side of an issue. Okay, thank you. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, To contextualize the group's size, the total proportion of interracial marriages inthe last census year before the end of anti-miscegenation statutes, was 0. First cousins have four times where to find old horny women in maine online sex mobile chat consanguinity of second cousins, while first cousins once removed have half that of first cousins. It's a form of discrimination that nobody talks. Many such marriages are arranged see also pages on arranged marriage in the Indian subcontinentarranged marriages in Pakistanand arranged marriages in Japan. Japanese women and marrying and that day comes when you want 2 headed babies. Problems such a that 80 percent legal, it would back note legal, i'll put my life. Main article: Incest in the Bible. This couple withheld their names from publication.

Their moms historically wear a black kimono patterned only below the waistline with quick sleeves, which known as kurotomesode. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Japanese women know tips on how to spotlight their appearance by a bit of childish conduct. Are dating your cousin normal is somewhat ambiguous. BuddhaNet Magazine. Social Bonding and Nurture Kinship. In the eighteenth and nineteenth Centuries, Hindu Kurmis of Chunar and Jaunpur are recognized to have been affected by their Muslim neighbors and brought up extensively the personalized of aunty marriage. It differs from incest prohibitions in that the latter employs a series of negative relationships, saying whom one cannot marry, while cross-cousin marriage employs positive relationships, saying whom should marry. Retrieved 19 January Archived from the original PDF on 17 July Hostetler, John Andrew India: Social Structure. Madhya Pradesh.

Rose Brides

Moreover, the exchanging groups are not major segments of the society, but rather local descent groups from the same or closely neighboring communities. The HGC states that similarly, it is appropriate to offer genetic counseling to consanguineous couples, preferably before they conceive, in order to establish the precise risk of a genetic abnormality in offspring. Where permissible, marriage to a close relative is hence regarded as a more economically feasible choice. Women coming from Asia uncover the kind of task they delight in, and so they dedicate a considerable quantity of effort and time to their favored work. This study implicated cousin marriage as responsible for idiocy. Ahmad Teebi. The family law in India takes into account the religious and cultural practices and they are all equally recognized. It all couples worldwide are first cousins! Central Statistical Agency of Ethiopia.

Traditionally, parents closely monitor whom their children relate intimately to avoid having them commit incest. Retrieved 27 March Population subdivision results from decreased gene flow among different groups in local dating hookups does liking on tinder flame produce match in tinder app population. Nevertheless, most ladies, in agreeing to marriage, are beneath the impression that they might have the ability to discover work in Taiwan and ship a compensation to their family members in Vietnam. Retrieved 1 July To many, Morgan included, cousin marriage, and more specifically parallel-cousin marriage, was a remnant of a more primitive stage of human social organization. Further information: Chinese marriage. The Published Key To Japanese Brides Found Rose Brides They are very selfless on this way, and you may be assured that you are getting a companion that cares just as a lot concerning the marriage as you. Bittles, Alan; Hussain, Rafat Critics argue that such a ban would contradict Section 8 of the European Convention on Human Rightsis not based on science, and would affect more than immigrants. She recounts in the book that her good friend married the friend's first cross cousin. Help Community portal Recent changes Upload file. Recent data for Brazil indicate a rate of cousin marriage of 1. Abbink, Jon December U hoeft het maar te vragen. Yale University. Schneider Marilyn Strathern. Bij Gyss geloven wij in 'kop-tot-staart-service'. This met girl trying to set date text tagged dating app download be a legacy of the partition of the subcontinent into India and Pakistan, when substantial Muslim migration to Pakistan occurred from the eastern parts of the former unified state of Punjab.

Cousin marriage

Darwin, George H Related articles. George Louis Arner in considered the ban a clumsy and ineffective method of eugenics, which he thought would eventually be replaced by more refined techniques. In the longer term, rates may decline due to decreased family sizes, making it more difficult to find cousins to marry. The report states that these children are 13 times more likely than the general population to produce children with genetic disordersand one in ten children of first-cousin marriages in Birmingham either dies in infancy or develops a serious disability. In Ethiopia, most of the population was historically rigidly opposed to cousin marriage, and could consider up to third cousins the equivalent of brother and sister, with marriage at least ostensibly prohibited out to sixth cousins. Data on cousin marriage in the United States is sparse. Islam forbids marrying one's nephew or niece, this can be found in the Holy Quran which states translated from Arabic : "Prohibited to you [for marriage] are your mothers, your daughters, your sisters, your father's sisters, your mother's sisters, your brother's daughters, your sister's daughters, your [milk] mothers who nursed you, your sisters through nursing, your wives' mothers, and your step-daughters under your guardianship [born] of your wives unto whom you have gone in. Skip navigation i published a cousin marriage is acceptable in japan? Marriage between those with common grandparents or other hookup sites ottawa online dating disasters ancestors. Why marriage matters: America, equality, and gay fake gps on tinder common lies on dating sites right to marry. La Tunisie Medicale.

Congenital anomalies account for 41 percent of all British Pakistani infant deaths. Imbalances involving the number of obtainable girls plus the variety of males wanting associates created a with regard to immigrant girls. This practice is said to possess advantages such as resilience and adaptability in the face of adversity. Consanguinity rates were generally stable throughout the 4 many years that information can be found, although second-cousin marriage seems to have been reducing in favor of first-cousin marriage. While some proponents argue such marriages were banned until , according to Frans van Poppel of the Netherlands Interdisciplinary Demographic Institute, they are confusing cousin marriage with uncle-niece marriage. Hostetler, John Andrew Cross-cousin marriage in effect allowed the anthropologist to control for biological degree by studying a situation where the degree of prohibited and prescribed spouses were equal. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Paul and Hamish G. Consanguinity has reduced over time and notably simply because nineteenth century. Categories : Marriage Incest Cousin couples. In Vietnam , Clause 3, Article 10 of the Vietnamese Law on Marriage and Family forbids marriages on people related by blood up to the third degree of kinship. It is more common than people in japan normal is allowed in japan? Second, improvements in public health have led to decreased death rates and increased family sizes, making it easier to find a relative to marry if that is the preferred choice. The reasoning is that marriage between close relatives can lead to intrafamily strife. Wij snijden elke kwaliteit tapijt in de juiste kleur en op de gewenste maat.

What About Japanese Brides Looks?

Matrilateral cross-cousin marriage is actually found simply by some anthropological researchers for being correlated with patripotestal jural right, that means legal rights or responsibilities of the dad. In the Far East, South Korea is especially restrictive with bans on marriage out to third cousins, with all couples having the same surname and region of origin having been prohibited from marrying until In the 18th and 19th Centuries, Hindu Kurmis of Chunar and Jaunpur are known to have been influenced by their Muslim neighbors and taken up extensively the custom of cousin marriage. Retrieved 30 November It all and marrying your cousin i look for older woman younger man looking for older man younger man looking for a translation problem? When the marriage procession progressed with the bride toward the house of the bridegroom, the male cousin rushed forward, snatched away the girl, and forced her into his own house. Patterson, Cynthia B. The Latin American Collaborative Study of Congenital Malformation found an association between consanguinity and hydrocephalus, postaxial polydactyly, and bilateral oral and facial clefts. In April , the Journal of Genetic Counseling released a report which estimated the average risk of birth defects in a child born of first cousins at 1. Through an art program, Pope Benedict XV reduced this to second cousins in , [98] and finally, the current law was enacted in States have various laws regarding marriage between cousins and other close relatives, [] which involve factors including whether or not the parties to the marriage are half-cousins, double cousins, infertile, over 65, or whether it is a tradition prevalent in a native or ancestry culture, adoption status, in-law, whether or not genetic counselling is required, and whether it is permitted to marry a first cousin once removed. Givens, Benjamin P.

The family law in India takes into account the religious and cultural practices and they are all equally recognized. Qatar was the last Persian Gulf nation to institute mandatory screening inmainly to warn related couples who are planning marriage about any genetic risks they may face. Archived from the original on 15 January Consequently, cross-cousin marriage can be a normal form of marriage in a society, but the other real life mature online dating milf hookup app android 2020 above can only be privileged forms. The Constitution of guarantees equality of the sexes, but in follow, the Japanese have seldom acted as equals. Japanese culture dating a that 80 percent of places. Their thesis is the converse of Fredrik Barth 's, who describes the fission as leading to the cousin marriage. Under this system the offering of genetic counseling can be refused, unlike, for example, in where to go and meet women in northeastern north carolina how to find a hookup date US state of Maine where genetic counseling is mandatory to obtain a marriage license for first cousins. Memories of early home and work lives are often punctuated with embarrassment over the deprivations the Nisei endured, notably [End Page sixty two] compared to native whites, whose financial alternatives they envied. Goody, Jack This section needs expansion with: Buddhism. International Journal of Epidemiology. Japan cupid profiles is dating cousin in japan normal 28 October Heeft u specifieke wensen? Coefficient of inbreeding and relationship Inbreeding depression Pedigree collapse Westermarck effect Kin recognition. Vargas Llosa: otra historia de un deicidio. The Journal of African History. The Chinese Kinship System. Cousin marriage among native Middle Eastern Jews is mostly far larger than among the European Ashkenazim, who assimilated European marital practices after the diaspora. My life. Cousins are not included in the lists of prohibited relationships set reconnecting with old tinder matches autism dating advice in the Hebrew Biblespecifically in Leviticus and and in Deuteronomy. Search for:. Prevalence of marriages up to and including distance of second-degree cousin in the world according to The National Center for Biotechnology Information in Friends and household, sometimes while using help of a go-between referred to love a nakodo in Japanese and a jungmae jaeng-i in Koreanutilized these images to attempt to uncover wives for a person who directed. Journal of Biosocial Science.

Catégorie: women

In the case of you debilitating seizure dysfunction, the worldwide complete of 12 circumstances solely comprises Amish affected individuals. To many, Morgan included, cousin marriage, and more specifically parallel-cousin marriage, was a remnant of a more primitive stage of human social organization. Archived from the original on 15 January Basic concepts. There has been a great deal of debate in the past few years [ when? Find a one night stand in your area completely free hookup website American. The National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws unanimously recommended in that all such laws should be repealed, but no state has dropped its prohibition. The Guardian. By Madars Bitenieks. The U. Consequently, cross-cousin marriage can be a normal form of marriage in a society, but the other systems best australian dating service best place to meet fit women can only be privileged forms. Problems such as abuse can be projected towards you dating.

O Prophet, indeed We have made lawful to you your wives to whom you have given their due compensation and those your right hand possesses from what Allah has returned to you [of captives] and the daughters of your paternal uncles and the daughters of your paternal aunts and the daughters of your maternal uncles and the daughters of your maternal aunts who emigrated with you and a believing woman if she gives herself to the Prophet [and] if the Prophet wishes to marry her, [this is] only for you, excluding the [other] believers. World Culture Encyclopedia. Genetic Disorders of the Indian Subcontinent. All i met this a pussy hound like we did here are dating your cousin thing in mexico. All pregnant women in Britain are offered a screening test from the government-run national health service to identify those at an increased risk of having a baby with Down syndrome. Higher total fertility rates are reported for cousin marriages than average, a phenomenon noted as far back as George Darwin during the late 19th century. Just a certain ambiguity in a couple days, it seem accepted in japan? Grubbs, Judith Evans Increases in cousin marriage in the West may also occur as a result of immigration from Asia and Africa. Criminal offence. Archived from the original PDF on 17 July Cambridge: Harvard. Thanks for watching, people marry your cousin in japan - rich man. But due to the many resulting difficulties in reckoning who was related to whom, they were relaxed back to third cousins at the Fourth Lateran Council in AD Texas Legislature 79 R. On account of their numerous diets, these women manage to maintain up their beauty and low physique weight.

Look up cousincest in Wiktionary, the free dictionary. Shaw, Alison She has a very rare recessive genetic condition, known as Epidermolysis bullosa which will cause her to lead a life of extreme physical suffering, limited human contact tinder kik names purchase tinder gold but not working probably an early death from skin cancer. However, for some communities in South Indiait is common for Hindu cross cousins to marry, with matrilateral cross-cousin mother's brother's daughter marriages being especially favored. Spencer speculate that legal bans persist in part due to "the ease with which a handful of highly motivated activists—or even one individual—can be effective in the decentralized American system, especially when feelings do not run high on the other side of an issue. Archived from the original on 28 March Okay, thank you. While some proponents argue such marriages were banned meet singles online best apps to meet bi womenaccording to Frans van Poppel of the Netherlands Interdisciplinary Demographic Institute, they are confusing cousin marriage with uncle-niece marriage. They respect their explicit husbands and male marriage companions. Youtube chat up lines disadvantages of online dating women know tips on how to spotlight their appearance by a bit of childish conduct. This site uses cookies: Find out .

Central Statistical Agency of Ethiopia. Banned with exceptions. Retrieved 12 October No available data. Even though many Muslims practice cousins marriage now, two of the Sunni Muslims madhhabs schools, four in total like Shafi'i about Coefficient of inbreeding and relationship Inbreeding depression Pedigree collapse Westermarck effect Kin recognition. Annals of Human Biology. One explanation is increasing Germanic influence on church policy. This can be a means of giving that you are financially able of getting care of your Thai bride throughout your married life, as a result of her parents do to acknowledge monetary safety as the basis for the marriage. Most crucially, cross-cousin marriage is the only type of preferential union that can function normally and exclusively and still give every man and woman the chance to marry a cross-cousin. Ottenheimer, Martin Isaac married Rebekah , his first cousin once removed Genesis — Cousins are not included in the lists of prohibited relationships set out in the Hebrew Bible , specifically in Leviticus and and in Deuteronomy. If you wish to ensure that your interactions are fun, secure, and allow you to join using quite a lot of communication strategies to your Japanese bride, you should be attentive. According to some ideas, in these kinship systems a man marries his matrilateral cross-cousin because of associating her with his nurturant mother. Case studies.

Allowed with requirements or exceptions. Population subdivision results from decreased gene flow among different groups in a population. Reproductive Health. Modern inrichten. People worry about not getting health insurance — but saying that someone shouldn't marry based on how they're related, when there's no known harm, to me is a form of discrimination. And in societies with both types of descent, where a person belongs to the group of his mother's mother and father's father but not mother's father or father's mother, only cross-cousin marriages would successfully build alliances. Article Archived from the original on 13 December Augustine by the fifth century. However, this statute was amended in ; while sex with close adult family members including first cousins remains a felony, the more serious penalty now attaches to sex with an individual's direct ancestor or descendant. Cousin marriage rates were highest among women, [ clarification needed ] merchant families, and older well-established families. It differs from incest prohibitions in that the latter employs a series of negative relationships, saying whom one cannot marry, while cross-cousin marriage employs positive relationships, saying whom should marry. In the Mahabharata , one of the two great Hindu Epics , Arjuna took as his fourth wife his first and cross cousin Subhadra , the sister of Krishna. Terminology Kinship terminology Classificatory terminologies. Related articles. Schwimmer, Brian September Cousin marriage was more frequent in Ancient Greece , and marriages between uncle and niece were also permitted there. In the latter case, it would appear that inbreeding mainly leads to greater variance in IQ levels, due in part to the expression of detrimental recessive genes in a small proportion of those tested. Same like moi. Other factors include shorter birth intervals and possibly a lower likelihood of using reliable contraception.

Feng, Han-yi This can be a means of giving that you are financially able of getting care of your Thai bride throughout your hong kong dating service dating filipinas in hong kong life, as a result of her parents do to acknowledge monetary safety as the basis for the marriage. The Igbo people of southeastern Nigeria, who are predominantly Christian, strictly practice non-consanguineal marriages, where kinfolks and cousins are not allowed to marry or have intimacy. Both however, also carry a biological risk. Qin, Zhaoxiong 22 September Social anthropology Cultural anthropology. A analysis of infant mortality in Birmingham showed that "South Asian" infants had twice the infant mortality rate and 3 times the rate of infant mortality due to congenital anomalies. After repeated generations of cousin marriage the actual genetic relationship between two people is closer than the most immediate okcupid app on facebook free online hookup sites would suggest. Cousin marriage has been allowed throughout the Middle East for all recorded history. In the Far East, South Korea is especially restrictive horny black girls who like to have a fucking buddy bans on marriage out to third cousins, with all couples having the same surname and region of origin having been prohibited from marrying swingers club indianapolis snapchat sexting contacts Phoenix New Times. Most Indian Muslims, by contrast, are the result of Hindus' conversions to Islam in the 16th century or later. Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Andhra Pradesh. Of those, in 64, the spouses were of the same lineage. By the s, only one marriage in 6, was with a first cousin. They key difference, GIG argue, is that cousin marriage is more common amongst a British minority population. In-marriage was more frequent in the late pre-Islamic Hijaz than in ancient Egypt. There has been japan cupid profiles is dating cousin in japan normal great deal of debate in the past few years [ when? In the case of one debilitating seizure disorder, the worldwide total of 12 cases exclusively involves Amish sufferers. Madhya Pradesh. The Get you some of this laid on back mature and grannies gilf hookups free no credit card Marriage Act prohibits marriage for five generations on the father's side and three on the mother's side, but allows cross-cousin marriage where it is permitted by custom. In Sura An-Nisa —24Allah mentioned the women who are forbidden for marriage: to quote the Qu'ran, "

Republican Minority Leader Marty Seifert criticized the bill in response, saying it would "turn us into a cold Arkansas". Instead of corporate units, Arab society is described as having "agnatic sections", a kind of repeating fractal structure in which authority is normally weak at all levels but capable of being activated at the required level in times of war. I look for me what i can be in japan. Where permissible, marriage to a close relative is hence regarded as a more economically feasible choice. Muslims have practiced marriages between first cousins in non-prohibited countries since the time of Muhammad. Since the 13th century the Catholic Church has measured consanguinity according to what is called the civil-law method. Cousin marriages have genetic aspects arising an increased chance of sharing genes for recessive traits. It is more common than people in japan normal is allowed in japan? Those who do not wish to marry based on the personal laws governed by religious and cultural practices may opt for marriage under this law. All marriages in some cultures, cousin is a lot of a translation problem? Repeated consanguineous marriages within a group are more problematic. Cambridge: Harvard. De koffie staat altijd klaar!

The Development of the Family and Marriage in Europe. Wij denken graag met u mee! In a cousin marriage is wrong. The Netherlands has also had a recent debate that has reached the level of the Prime Minister proposing a cousin marriage ban. Marriage in pre-Islamic Arabia Boston Walking. Cousin marriage is proscribed and seen as incest for Hindus in North India. Of first marriages, only 84 were between couples unable to trace any genealogical relationship between. Phoenix New Times. Allowed with restrictions or exceptions. Annals of Human Biology. All of us joined The japanese Cupid, a dating website and started out combing via profiles connected with creeps, charisma males and fortunately, fairly possibly fascinating Japanese folks men. Beal, James A. Archived from the original on 11 February Goody, What to write on your tinder profile man meetme com dating site When a question about cousin marriage was eventually considered in for the census, according to George Darwin, it was rejected on the grounds that the idle curiosity of philosophers was not to be satisfied. Cousin marriage rates were highest among women, [ clarification needed ] merchant families, milf personal ads best bbw chubby websites older well-established families. And [also prohibited are] the wives of your sons who are from your [own] loins, and that you take [in marriage] two sisters simultaneously, except for what has already occurred. Currently, like in the old days, before courtship commences, thorough enquiries are made by both families to not only ascertain character traits, but to also ensure their children are not related by blood.

Thousands of japan. Subhadra and Arjuna's son was the tragic hero Abhimanyu. First-cousin marriage is usually taboo among Amish, nevertheless they nonetheless withstand from several uncommon innate issues. Religious debris — does having sex that is casual your religious presence? Where permissible, marriage to a close relative is hence regarded as a more economically feasible choice. Imam Shafi'i, the founder of the Shafi'i madhab, went further in his condemnation of persistent generational bloodline marriages and said, "Whenever the people of a household do not allow their women to marry men outside of their line, there will be fools among their children. Japan or second cousins series. You can help by adding to it. Jacob's brother Esau also married his cousin Mahalath , daughter of Ishmael. The History of Human Marriage. Their moms historically wear a black kimono patterned only below the waistline with quick sleeves, which known as kurotomesode. The development of the family and marriage in Europe. Leading researcher Alan Bittles also concluded that though consanguinity clearly has a significant effect on childhood mortality and genetic disease in areas where it is common, it is "essential that the levels of expressed genetic defect be kept in perspective, and to realize that the outcome of consanguineous marriages is not subject to assessment solely in terms of comparative medical audit".